Writing (like acting) is one of those professions where you put yourself out there. Sometimes people will like you and sometimes people won't. I want to take the time today to address those times when someone hates your writing.
Does it hurt? You better believe it. But in most cases, it is probably just a small sting and if you really listen to the critique, you might find the rationale behind the critique. But here is the issue I really want to address.
When you get a bad critique, don't just go running to your friends and get sympathy. Sure, get a few pats on the back but draw the line. I have seen on blogs and listened to writers at conventions whining and moaning about all of the unfair treatment they got on their last book. What is interesting is that the writer is always complaining. Time and time again they get a review that is less than satisfying and off they go on their new round of poor me.
Look get over it. Learn from it and make some changes in your writing.
And as for the good friends out there, get that writer moving and slap some sense into them. I don't care how good of a friend they are, the reviewer might have just been right!
Scott Eagan is the literary agent for Greyhaus Literary Agency. Greyhaus Literary Agency focuses exclusively on the traditional romance and women's fiction genres. Scott believes through increased education as well as communication between publishing professionals and authors, these two genres can continue to be a strong force in the publishing world.
Wednesday, February 4, 2009
Monday, February 2, 2009
When two or more agree
We always talk about the subjectivity of the publishing business and how what is good for one person might be bad for someone else. This is completely true, however, I have to draw a line with this one.
I think writers have their blinders on when there have been several critics that say the same thing about their writing, and yet they seem to think that they might be wrong. Sure, they may be, but darn it, when several people are saying the same thing, then maybe you as a writer might be the person at fault.
When I talk to writers, I always stress the importance of getting feedback from a lot of people. Not only do you get a chance to hear a lot of perspectives, but it also gives you a chance to follow potential patterns in the comments. Seeing those patterns should give you something to look for and edit later. I should stress though, that when I say to get different perspectives, I mean to find people with very different points of view. If the only people you go to are people who think like you, then you aren't getting what you want.
I think writers have their blinders on when there have been several critics that say the same thing about their writing, and yet they seem to think that they might be wrong. Sure, they may be, but darn it, when several people are saying the same thing, then maybe you as a writer might be the person at fault.
When I talk to writers, I always stress the importance of getting feedback from a lot of people. Not only do you get a chance to hear a lot of perspectives, but it also gives you a chance to follow potential patterns in the comments. Seeing those patterns should give you something to look for and edit later. I should stress though, that when I say to get different perspectives, I mean to find people with very different points of view. If the only people you go to are people who think like you, then you aren't getting what you want.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)