Showing posts with label Blog Flog. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Blog Flog. Show all posts

Tuesday, February 10, 2015

Why Literature Is Struggling Right Now - Just some observations

We are hearing all of the time of the quality of literature and the material being written today. Yesterday, I wrote on the idea that it is you who dictates what you want and what you will get out of your writing career. I want to extend on that today.

So answer me this....


  • Why is it that authors, who have Ph.Ds and are writing books on "well researched topics" would submit their non-fiction work to the Greyhaus Literary Agency that only represents romance and women's fiction???
  • Why is it that authors, who are supposedly smart enough to write a novel length text, will submit stories using an online form that states the minimum word count required will still proceed to submit something far below that amount?
  • Why will authors submit stories to editors who, in their submission guidelines state they only take submissions from agents?
  • Why will authors send projects to the same editor and agent, after being rejected because it isn't the right genre, and then send a similar project?
  • Why will authors sign up for pitch sessions at conferences with editors and agents with projects the editors and agents aren't acquiring after it is posted in conference paperwork and the information is online?
and finally...


  • Why do writers accuse the editors and agents for not being open to new projects when they do all of the things I asked about above?

Sorry for the rant today, but I felt the need for a real big Blog Flog Today!


Wednesday, October 29, 2014

It's Another Reminder - Read the Submission Guidelines: A BLOG FLOG!


So, this last weekend I spent a few hours going though submissions, One of the submissions came from an author who had already submitted to me in the past. I don't mind when authors resubmit. I am always hoping to see growth. But here is the issue:
  • The first submission was for a genre I do not represent. I clearly stated that in the reply which always comes with my digital signature that includes the link to my web page where the guidelines are also posted.
  • The second submission was for another genre I do not represent. I again replied stating that it would be a good idea to review the submission guidelines.
But then here comes a third one. At this point, we are hoping that authors have figured things out. But noooooo! This is for a project ALSO in a genre I don't even remotely represent.

Again, I reply back stating that it is not a genre I represent and he should indeed review the submission guidelines, 

For this person, I also went on to note that editors and agents only represent certain genres. We do this because of our expertise in the field, our interest, or simply (in the case of editors) this is the position we were hired for. We don't limit our genres because we are closed minded our out to screw the dedicated author and their personal voice.

But wait, this gets better. 

The reply I get is:

I am merely an author trying to break through ice thin of thick, therefore, I am asking for one final review. Though, yes, you have spoken, but it only seems beneficial to reach out once more. As I'm sure many people probably annoy you with similar request in their grave attempts for contract & publication, but maybe you'd be willing to spare the time? And yes, I take into full understanding you are very busy w/ a multiple of clients, projects & other varieties to which you owe me nothing. I'm simply trying to reach out one last time.

There are several things to address here:

THE AUTHOR IS IGNORING, ONCE AGAIN THE SUBMISSION GUIDELINES - I find it interesting that the author is ignoring the real reason I rejected the project. When you send something that is not what we represent, we let you know. Now I do know some editors and agents will not let you know because this information is clearly available in multiple sources, but Greyhaus does let you know. There is simply nothing beneficial about "reading out once more" and wanting "one final review". Agents are not here as a review service. There are plenty of review services with editors who will do this. In the end, the real issue is - if you do get a reason why the editor or agent rejected you, then follow those guidelines.

THE AUTHOR IS RELYING ON EMOTION AND NOT PROFESSIONALISM Look, this is a business and we are looking for writers with a sense of professionalism. This will also include letters that demonstrate how this person will act and behave in public when it is time to market their projects. When we see someone relying on the the fallacies of "Appealing to Pity" and "Appealing to Emotions", these are huge red flags. How will this person react when we send revision letters? How will this person act when there is a not so positive review.

Last week, I spent time talking about what I look for in a submission. This is that element I spoke of when we discussed reviewing the submission for who the author is. 

THIS IS A REASON WHY MANY AGENTS DON'T SEND REJECTION LETTERS It is this reason that many agents limit how much, if any information they send back to an author in a rejection letter. This also includes why they don't respond when you want to discuss the book further after a rejection, or you try to argue it. This leaves the door open for someone to start swamping the mail email with more reasons and justifications. 

I should also add that this is why contests such as the RITA and the GOLDEN HEART eliminated the comments from the preliminary judges. There were too many, shall I dare use the word, "psycho" authors out there who went ballistic over a rejection. 


So, what did we learn from this today? If you are thinking of replying to a rejection, letter, make sure you know what you are doing before you hit send. What is the message you are sending to that editor or agent. Along the same lines, I want you to make sure you review those submission guidelines of the editors and agents. This is not rocket science people! 

* * *

And some final notes. First of all, it is a shame this author, as well as those other authors out there who continually send projects without reading the submission guidelines don't read this blog. Maybe if they spent some more time doing their research and learning the business, they might find some more success. And secondly, this weekend 34% of the submissions I received were for projects in genres I didn't represent. They got letters back from me and hopefully they won't do what this author decided to do.

Monday, August 29, 2011

Blog Flog Time!!! - The Use of Public Forums


I love the line "If you can't say anything good, talk about the weather." This idea is so relevant for today's "brief" discussion.

One of the things I really dislike about many of the social media sites are those individuals who decide to use it as a forum for "selling" their own ideas or "trashing on someone or something." Let me stop here and say the issue does not come from people stating their own mind, I am referring to those people who seem to think it is appropriate to use other individuals forums to do this. Those people on Twitter who simply link your name to their products selling who knows what. The people who "Post a comment" on a Facebook page simply to advertise their product. Or those people who get on blogs and comment, not to provide content to a dialogue but to simply sell their own products.

There are a lot of agents and editors out there that have blogs designed to provide "one" approach, or "tips" for writers to learn something about the business or their craft. Recently, however, I have seen one published author, jumping around to blogs not contributing to the conversation but finding a way to slam the traditional approach only to lead to advertising to their own workshop and book, as if it is only approach to the success. Tsk, tsk, tsk. Maybe, instead of making those comments, you should have discussed the weather outside your own window. Had you done that, you might have maintained your "professional" image. And honestly, if you are the agent of this person, I would strongly encourage a serious conversation with the writer. Not only did they ruin their professional image, but may have tarnished a bit the agencies reputation.

Matthew Lippman describes a great learning environment as a "community of inquiry." In other words, this is a place where everyone can learn and also has something to add to that over-all learning. Contributions such as these individuals I speak of do nothing to add to that learning.

In my humble opinion,

Scott

Wednesday, July 27, 2011

Blog Flog! And NOT A Letter of Rejection

Ahhh, it has been a while since I posted one of these, but, once again, I had Grade A Material to work with here. Along the same lines, I can kill two birds with one stone here. First, this is a  chance for you to see what agents adn editors do get on a pretty regular basis; Secondly, to give you some insight into the rationale for many of our rejections; and finally, to provide an open letter that IS NOT a rejection (You will understand further in this post).

Dear Sir or Madam,

Pleae be advised this letter is being sent to multiple literary agencies as well as editors who work for publishers, I am ware this is not your usual method of recieving what you think is a submission. This is not a submission. It is, in point of fact a search for an agent, pr publisher's in-house editor, who has what it takes to see and understand my vision and help me maximize opportunities associated with that vision so that both of us can earn a lot of money.

O.K. at least she told me this was a simultaneous submssion, but at least take the time to personalize it. Not a major hang up though. Where we run into the problem is the massive amount of verbage at the end of this first paragraph. She is supposedly not submitting anything to us, just looking for an agent (FOR WHAT???) And don't get me started on "editors who work for publishers."

Now at this point, I am not going to bore you with the next two paragraphs that outline all of the amazing things this person has done with writing Let me just say that we have a huge list of writing things that should tell me the person knows how to write, but by the end of the first page of this submission we have seen nothing. Here is the funny part. Several of her published books were focused on successful resume writing skills.

Now we get to the end of the first page and she tells me of the books that she has available. One novella; One Memoir, which she believes is perfect for an HBO or Showtime Movie, (wow I wish I was that popular); and one crime novel; another resume book... Oh, and this is the good one Another book whose title and scope are bing kept under wraps until it is complete, but the contests for it are now being researched and compiled... and the list goes on and on.

This is for the author now and coming from the "not a rejection" portion of this post. I am glad you are writing in all of these areas but as you know from the information clearly posted on my website, Greyhaus only represents romance and women's fiction, but since the stories you have (but are not submitting) are not in either of these areas, I just don't think I can help you (but please note this is not a rejection or acceptance since you are not writing a submission letter).

But wait, there is more. I'm only going to tap into the highlights here...

She does have a full parargraph of how she is a businessperson and how she is only interested in agents who are willing to see her career goals and work with her. She also goes on to say that using the old model of selling books is not going to work any more and has proven to be a complete failure. Of course, she is going through an agent to sell her books (woops, forgot she isn't submitting anything).

If, after discussion by phone (because she refused to send a SASE but that is OK, because this isn't a submission), it is mutually beneficial to meet in person and you will not be in [insert city name] in the foreseeable future, I am willing to travel. I am not foolish with my money. I will not signe on a deal that is bad for me and I will nto allow an agent to do so in my name....

So, apparently I am supposed to be totally amazed at what she is not pitching to me that I am to hop on an airplane and fly immediately to her to beg her to sign on with me. But, even then, it sounds as if I have to go through several trials and tests to evaluate my willingness and worthiness.

And her comes the P.S....

I am not looking for anyone whose first inclination in reply is "Please see our submission guidelines" (this isn't a submission), "You really need to check out... (a publication or website), or "You need to educate yourself on the marketplace" (that's why I want an agent, they are supposed to know the market).
Nor am I looking for anyone who will tell me something is impossible  that I cannot do that, or I am not allowed to do that.
But if you are one of the best agents, that wouldn't have been what you would have said anyway.

Well, I honestly don't know how to answer this. It's not a submission. You don't want to hear this is something I don't represent. You don't want me to remind you the information is posted on the website. And, you don't want me to recommend learning what goes into a submission letter because I, as an agent, already know what goes into a submission letter. Hmm, what do I say?

You don't want me to tell you something is impossible, even if it might be. O.K. I won't tell you then. You don't want me to tell you this is something I cannot do or not allowed to do it, so I won't tell you that either.

I guess the only thing I can say is for someone who, is "not foolish with my money"  the first class postage you put on this letter and those that went out to who knows how many other people, the money for the paper and the color printing you did with the letter, the business cards with your photo on it, and the time it took to do all of this, will get you a lot of one thing. No letters and no responses from editors or agents. Heck, we have nothing to respond to.

Best of luck with your writing.

Scott Eagan

Thursday, April 21, 2011

Time for a BLOG FLOG!

Had to add this for a Thursday evening.

I get it. You are an amazing writer! The world falls at your feet when you enter a room. Your "beta-readers" all think the world of you. BUT...

If you submit a project to an agent that does not represent that genre, expect a rejection.

BUT...

Do not respond to an agent after that rejection blaming us for your lack of research. Do you yell at a plumber who refuses to come out and fix your car, blaming them for their lack of ability to "expand their thinking."

Sorry to say it, publishing is no different than any other business.

Tuesday, December 14, 2010

Blog Flog - You're Missing the Point People!


There are days when I read the responses from writers on my posts and I have to really laugh. This is not so much from the authors telling jokes, but authors who make comments clearly showing me they are missing the point.

Let me highlight a few of the ideas that have come up over the last several months.
  • We talk about query letters and people are obsessed with the grammar elements instead of hearing the comment that your pitch and high concept element of the letter needs to sell us.
  • Someone commented about the query letters saying it is nothing more than a cover letter we "slap on a resume." Yes it is! But you would be surprised how many resumes are rejected because the cover letter didn't sell the product.
  • We talk about targeting your story and writers feel this is limiting your freedom of creativity. Again, this is not about stopping your creativity but thinking of market analysis and seeing this as business.
  • One agent makes a comment on a blog and then is slammed because a writer heard something different from someone else. Did anyone remember the comment about publishing being subjective.
  • Just because you or a friend did something, it doesn't mean it is a trend or the standard.

I think the whole point to consider is to take what you can use. Think BIG PICTURE here and don't focus strictly on the smaller points.

Now, off to play serious catch up after a great break with the family. Of course leaving 85 degrees to this disgusting rain and wind isn't working for me.

Scott

Friday, November 12, 2010

Another thought on E-printing programs - And a Blog Flog!


This one is going out to those e-printing programs now on the rise across the internet and to those that write books that frankly aren't worthy to be printed.


For those of you following the publishing news lately, you have likely heard about the book being marketed online with a major publisher attempting to justify and make easier the behavior of pedophiles. Honestly, in my humble opinion, I was sickened when I saw this book.





Obviously, there is the issue of the topic. I understand that people have the right to say things that they want (with limits), however, as I listened to the author talk, truly trying to justify his topic and making it sound justifiable. That was too much for me personally.





But, since this is a blog focused on publishing, I want to bring up my complaint with this book in that light. When I saw this, it once again supported my argument about the availabilty of e-printing to everyone. Programs being operated by major book retailers or online sites seem to really be putting money ahead of quality.





I do understand there is a downside to this. I am thinking of the authors out there that were once published with traditional publishers and are now selling their books electronically that they own the rights for. But, now that this issue has come up with this other book, there will be an effect on these other authors. I can clearly see policies, legal decisions and the like coming up that will now put a serious bump in the e-publishing market.





I have said this in the past, and I will say this again. Publishing is open to everyone, but not everything should be published. No, this is not a matter of being an elitist and saying people aren't worthy. This is simply a matter of looking at publishing as a business.





Just my thoughts on this.

Wednesday, November 10, 2010

Blog Flog!

Stay professional people. Sending queries that sound like you are writing to your best friend is not business like. While you might feel that you know me from the things you have read here on the blog, this does not mean that your letters pitching your story to me should be casual.
Hey Scott,
I bet you thought I dropped off the face of the Earth. I know it has been a while but I have a really cool story I want to throw your direction.
Sorry to say it but you have now earned yourself a rejection. You might have the best dang story out there but your lack of professionalism just cost you that extra read.
Now, I know that there are other agents out there that will claim that the query isn't going to make that big of an impact on them. They will likely use that same line we always hear, "It's all about the story." But honestly, I am betting they will find something wrong with that project.
This is a business. While writing for many is a hobby, if you want to earn money you have to treat it just like any job. If you were applying for a job with a major corporation, would you be that casual or would you be professional and show the employer you are a person to be taken seriously?

Friday, July 30, 2010

Blog Flog - Conference Etiquette

Tsk, tsk, tsk!
Remember, if you see an agent or editor in the hallway, it is OK to ask if you can pitch.

Calling their room, that's a no no.

Friday, June 18, 2010

And It's Time For Some Blog Flogging!!!!!


Here come some biggies...

  • Submitting stories that aren't finished to any agent looking at fiction is a sure sign of getting a rejection. Sure, some might say we'll look at it when it is done, but most can just send a quick no and keep moving through their piles.
  • Not telling an agent everything about your writing and being overly vague may cause the agent to go looking. When we find that you write in a genre we don't represent, but were trying to get us interested in it by not telling us, the odds are you will be seeing a rejection. Be up-front and honest!
  • Query tracker is fine (as well as many of these other sites) however, please review what the agent really wants. I have done all I can to make it really obvious on Query Tracker, for example, to tell you I only take romance and women's fiction. Last time I checked, stories in the Tom Clancy style don't quite fit with romances.
  • Using a form letter for submissions is fine, but make sure you don't include incorrect information... Telling me you got my information from a source that I am not listed in is a sure red flag that tells me you don't do your research.
  • Finally... MY NAME IS NOT MR. GREYHAUS!!!!!! This is the agency name!

Whew!

Thursday, June 3, 2010

BLOG FLOG!





I apologize for this automatic reply to your email.


To control spam, I now allow incoming messages only from senders I have approved beforehand.


If you would like to be added to my list of approved senders, please fill out the short request form (see link below). Once I approve you, I will receive your original message in my inbox. You do not need to resend your message. I apologize for this one-time inconvenience.


Click the link below to fill out the request:


So sorry people but I am not doing this! If you sent me a submission, you should have put me on the safe list! If you sent me a submission on
Tuesday, June 01, 2010 5:32 PM via my form page, and it was a project of 40,000 words, you might want to check your spam folder!

Sunday, February 28, 2010

BLOG FLOG!



Tsk, Tsk, Tsk.

We sort of a have a double whammy here.

A) Making me go to the post office to pick up your submission.
B) Making me pay for it since you failed to put enough postage on it.

Whaaaaatttt?

Friday, January 15, 2010

BLOG FLOG! - Friday


I have several today.

  • When I open up submissions, I shouldn't feel like I am opening up that present from your parents. You know the ones. They give you a big box, and inside of it are more and more little ones. When you do get to the present, you find it's socks. A simple binder clip in one envelope is fine.
  • Personal art work for your book? Drawing me images of your character on the outside of the envelope? Weird.
  • 2 inch margins?
  • Remember, paragraphs are indented and yes, this includes dialogue.
  • 14 pt., bold print summaries then shifting to blue, 10 pt, single spaced, italic font is not working for me.

Whew, 5 flogs in one day. My arm hurts!


Sunday, January 10, 2010

BLOG FLOG!


Tsk, tsk, tsk.


Sending me an e-query that only discusses an abstract theme that really says nothing... combined with a lack of character, confliction or anything.


Why do I want to sign a vague theme.


Wednesday, December 23, 2009

BLOG FLOG!



This one goes out to all those people who have forgotten what the holidays are about. Remember there is a reason we are celebrating and family is important. If you have forgotten the real reason for celebrating, you might want to think about the line from Sense and Sensibility. If you can't think of something good to say, talk about the weather. But please remember, when you do this, keep it to yourself and stay out of the way from those people that are really celebrating.


As for me, I am celebrating with my family and nothing is going to stop me from focusing on that.


Sunday, December 20, 2009

BLOG FLOG!

This one goes out to all of those writers that aren't thinking when you send submissions to the agents! Remember, it is Christmas time, the lines at the post office just plain suck! So, when you send a manuscript to us, wanting delivery confirmation and a signature, you are not getting on our good side. I don't want to stand in line for this.





So for you, here is your Blog Flog!



Look, if you want to know if your story makes it, just use tracking. Check it out on your computer! Please, no more signatures!

Scott

Saturday, December 19, 2009

BLOG FLOG!

I get this one!


Remember to order tickets to small community theatre production early next year. Thought we could get the tickets at the door.


Woops.


Scott

BLOG FLOG!

I was talking to a writer yesterday and asked her how her writing was going. She was doing the NaNoWriMo. She fell off the pace but when the stress of writing decreased, she felt she was writing much better. So it was time to check in again.





She has not been writing. She had all of these "reasons" why she hadn't gotten back to the story.





So for Ms. Leslie, you get the first Blog Flog!



Get back to writing, NOW!




Scott