Should You Write In A Lot Of Different Genres?

I see authors doing this all of the time. They start out writing in one genre, then they hear that something else is hot, so they jump into that genre. Sometimes, authors are just writing in a lot of different genres at the same time. So, the question before us today is: Is this wise?

Personally, as an agent, I would argue no and there are several reasons for this.

First, you need to write in a genre you understand. Sure, you might read a lot of different genres, but there are specific nuances that you might not be fully cognizant of when you read a book. It isn't just about looking up things on the internet. It is about understanding the "why" of the nuance. For example, if you think that YA or New Adult is hot and you start writing your next great novel, ask yourself how much you really know about the current YA or New Adult culture? If all of your knowledge is based on what you just binge watched on Netflix, or the life "as you remember it" when you grew up, this is a big mistake.

Secondly, it is important for you to really get to know your genre and get REALLY good at it. You are developing your "brand." Regardless of whether you are taking the traditional route to publishing or taking the self-pub approach, your readers want to know when they see your latest book on the shelf, they are getting what they fell in love with. They do not want to open it up to find you have done the whole bait and switch. 

Finally, this deals with how an editor or agent will work with you. Let's say I am pitching your work to an editor. They like your voice but the story just doesn't quite work. Often, the editor will say, "what else you do have?" If I don't have a genre that works, then the conversation is over. The same will work when you pitch to an editor or agent. We don't need to see linked books, but we do need to see similar genres. 

Now, I am not going to say writing is bad in all cases. I am simply saying to venture forth with caution.